A Shipshewana police dashcam filmed the proposal he thought he had ruined
Nicholas Caldwell missed his moment at the town’s Christmas lighting and spent the evening thinking he had let Andrea Ibarra down. The town marshal’s camera had been recording.
20 November 2026
Photo: WSBT
Nicholas Caldwell knew a few weeks into dating Andrea Ibarra that he wanted to marry her. He waited for the right moment, and picked the night Shipshewana switches on its Christmas lights, when more than 45,000 people fill the small Indiana town.
The plan
He meant to time it to the countdown. As the numbers ran down to zero she would turn round, and there he would be. That is not how it went. The countdown came and went, and the two of them ended up in the middle of the four-way crossing in the centre of town.
It happened to be the place where they had their first date, about a year earlier. He asked her there, and she said yes.
He still thought he had got it wrong. “I was actually pretty disappointed after everything happened because I felt I didn’t give her a special enough moment,” he told WSBT.
The camera
Town Marshal Nicholas Byroad was on patrol during the lighting, talking with a couple of other officers, when he glanced across. “I looked over, I was like, ‘I think he’s proposing to her,’” he said. The officers watched the couple kiss and started clapping. He knew he had it, because the dash camera in his car was recording.
Nobody had set out to film anything. The camera was on, and it was pointing the right way.
Finding them
That left the marshal with a recording of two strangers getting engaged and no idea who they were. Christine Yoder, the town council president, put the clip on social media to find them, and within a few hours people had.
Once they were found, the town showed them the video and gave them a basket of presents. It was the first time either of them had seen it. They had not known it existed. Yoder described the lighting as “like being in the middle of a Hallmark movie with all of the lights.”
They have a wedding to plan now, and they say they will be back at the lighting every year.
Carry a story in five words
We run a game called Long Story Short: one real news sentence a day, and you keep the five words that carry it. Today’s is below. Do play.
How to play
One real news sentence. The job is to keep the five words that carry the story and let the rest go, then guess. Blue means the right word in the right place, orange the right word in the wrong place.
Yesterday: Children made washi diploma paper, pulling mulberry fibre across a wooden frame exactly as papermakers in that valley have done for eight hundred years. The five were children made washi diploma paper.