What's in two million recipes

We read 2.2 million recipes from American recipe websites to find the dishes people write down most, the handful of ingredients nearly all of them share, and what you could cook tonight with what's already in your kitchen.

A Data Drop by sheets.works

Every line behind this box is the name of a real recipe, picked at random from the collection, names in all.

The collection is RecipeNLG, 2,231,142 recipes that researchers at Poznań University of Technology gathered from sites like Food.com, Allrecipes, Epicurious and an old site called cookbooks.com, whose recipes read as if they were typed up from family and church cookbooks. After removing copies of the same recipe there are 2,089,091 left.

Casseroles

The names in red have the word casserole in them. Across the whole collection, 80,564 recipe names do, which is about one recipe in every 26.

Chicken casserole

Every name on screen now is a real chicken casserole from the collection, of the 4,042. When we group recipes by name, ignoring words like easy, best and Grandma's, it is the dish people have written down more than any other, and almost all of them gave it the same plain name: the 4,042 recipes use only different spellings.

The recipe Americans write down most is chicken casserole

There are 4,042 different chicken casserole recipes in the collection, about 1,250 more than the dish in second place, and the next two places also go to casseroles.

The list below is the top 20 dishes by how many versions exist. It reads like the table at a church supper: broccoli casserole, cheese ball, meat loaf, chili, fruit salad, baked beans, pecan pie, cranberry salad.

The grey column on the right explains it: for most of these dishes, nine out of ten versions come from cookbooks.com, the site built on typed-up family and community cookbooks, so this is the menu of American home cooks writing for each other. Banana bread is the most modern dish on the list, and even there seven versions in ten come from the old cookbooks.

A cornflower CorningWare casserole dish with a golden crumb top
different chicken casserole recipes.

of the 4,042 chicken casseroles are different from each other. The single most common version, chicken, cream of mushroom soup, onion soup mix and rice, appears only four times.

So the most popular dish is also one that almost nobody makes the same way. Most cooks start from chicken and a can of creamy soup baked until it bubbles, then add their own topping or vegetable, and that small change was enough for them to write it down as their own.

What goes into a chicken casserole

Every chicken casserole has chicken in it, so we left that off. The bars show what else goes in: out of every 100 versions, how many use each ingredient.

The sauce comes from a can: 56 in 100 use condensed cream of chicken soup and 39 use cream of mushroom, often both together, so nobody has to make a sauce from scratch.

Meat loaf

Eggs are in 91 of every 100 meat loaves, ground beef in 83 and onion in 80. Four in ten use ketchup, and a third use breadcrumbs to hold it together.

Chili

A typical chili needs nine ingredients. Ground beef, onion and chili powder are in about four out of five. Only about a third use garlic, and about a third use kidney beans.

Pecan pie

Pecan pie is close to a fixed formula: eggs in 99 versions out of 100, butter in 83, then vanilla and sugar. The 28 in 100 that use flour are probably counting the crust, and about one in six simply asks for a ready-made pie shell.

Banana bread

Banana bread is a baking recipe, so it looks like one: eggs in 96 versions out of 100, flour in 90, sugar in 88 and baking soda in 79. Butter is in fewer than half of them.

A few ingredients turn up everywhere

Across all two million recipes, a small group of ingredients does most of the work, and the first few are in a quarter to a half of everything.

As you scroll, each square below stands for one recipe out of a hundred, and the dark ones are the recipes that use the ingredient.

Salt
46
in every 100 recipes

Salt is in 46 of every 100 recipes, and four in ten of those are sweet, because cakes and cookies take a pinch too.

Butter is in 30 of every 100 recipes, and almost half of those aren't sweet at all: 33,102 casseroles call for it.

Eggs are in 28 of every 100 recipes. They are in more cake recipes than sugar is: 90,268 cakes use eggs, against 77,082 that use sugar.

Sugar is level with eggs. After cakes, pies and cookies, it turns up most in something you might not expect: 33,626 recipes with salad in the name. We come back to those salads below.

Onion is in 22 of every 100 recipes and is the first thing on this list that no cake would use. Its most common homes are casseroles and soups.

Flour is level with onion. Two thirds of the recipes that use it are sweet, and the other third are savoury.

Garlic is in 20 of every 100 recipes, most often sauces and soups. That average hides a big split between old recipes and new ones, which we come back to below.

After those seven, the numbers drop quickly. Black pepper is in 18 recipes out of every 100, milk in 16, olive oil in 13 and vanilla in 12, and by the 30th ingredient on the list you are down to three or four recipes in every hundred.

Behind them sit about 170,000 other ingredient names, and most of those are used by only a handful of recipes. That long tail matters later on, because it is the reason so many recipes have one ingredient you don't have.

What goes with what

Some ingredients almost always arrive together. Pick one to see, out of every 100 recipes that use it, how many also use each of its most common partners.

Salt sits near the top for nearly everything, so look at the second and third places, which is where the real partnerships show up: olive oil and garlic, butter and sugar, tomato and onion.

The closest pairs

Common pairs are not always close ones, because salt and eggs turn up together all the time simply because both are everywhere. So we also measured how much more often two ingredients appear together than they would if cooks picked ingredients at random. The pairs below are the tightest among the 150 most common ingredients, and they read like a map of cuisines: sesame oil and sesame seeds, coriander and turmeric, cilantro and lime, and from the old cookbooks, pineapple and marshmallows.

"26×" means the two appear together 26 times as often as chance would predict. Only pairs found together in at least 2,000 recipes are included.

Most recipes need about eight things

Count the ingredients in each recipe, leaving out water, and the most common answer is seven or eight.

About one recipe in four gets by with five or fewer, and only one in twenty needs fifteen or more.

Number of ingredients in a recipe, and how many recipes need that many. The green columns are seven and eight.

The top dishes sit right in the middle. A typical cheese ball or fruit salad needs six things, most casseroles need seven, and chili, lasagna, beef stroganoff and potato salad need nine or ten.

Grandma's kitchen and today's

The recipes from the old cookbook site and the ones from today's food sites ask for very different things.

On one side are 787,461 recipes from cookbooks.com, typed up in the shorthand of old family and church cookbooks, where 81 out of every 100 write a cup as "c." On the other are 299,031 recipes from today's food sites, Epicurious, MyRecipes, Food Network, Food52 and Serious Eats, where only about one in a hundred writes it that way. The collection does not record the year each recipe was written, so we can't date them, but the two kitchens cook very differently.

Grandma's kitchen
recipes
Today's food sites
recipes

The can of soup

One old recipe in 23 uses a can of cream of mushroom soup. On today's sites it is one in 501, about twenty times rarer.

Cool Whip

Cool Whip is named in one old recipe in 23, about as often as the soup. A fifth of those recipes are pies, a fifth are salads and a fifth are cakes. Today it is one in 474.

Jell-O

Jell-O is in one old recipe in 30. Remember the sweet salads? Four in ten Jell-O recipes have salad in the name. On today's sites it is one in 595.

Garlic

Garlic was in one old recipe in 13 and is now in one in three, roughly four times as often. Garlic powder went the other way, from one old recipe in 50 to one in 667.

Olive oil

Olive oil went from one old recipe in 48 to one in four today, about fourteen times as often.

Cilantro and lime

Cilantro went from one recipe in 340 to one in 16, and lime from one in 181 to one in 17. More than half of all old recipes ask for something by the can, box, packet or jar, against about one in five today.

Close-up of a cream-coloured oven temperature dial

Half of all ovens are set to 350

731,925 recipes tell you an oven temperature, and half of them say 350°F. The next most common, 375°F, is used by about one recipe in eight.

Before ovens had thermostats, recipes asked for a slow, moderate or quick oven and left the cook to judge it. When ovens with numbered dials arrived in American homes in the 1920s and 30s, a moderate oven became 325 to 375, and 350 sits right in the middle. Those three settings still cover 71 out of every 100 recipes that name a temperature, so recipes mostly still say "moderate oven", only as a number.

It depends on what you're baking

We split the recipes by the kind of dish in their name. Brownies, meat loaf and casseroles are the most loyal to 350, at about three or four recipes in every five. Muffins most often go to 400 and biscuits to 450, and only about three pizzas or roasts in ten use 350, and most of the rest go hotter.

Share of recipes of each kind that use 350°F as their first oven temperature.

How far your kitchen gets you

A recipe only works if you have every ingredient on its list. So we asked: if you stocked a kitchen with the most useful ingredients first, how many recipes could you cook?

We started with an empty shelf and kept adding whichever ingredient finished the most recipes. Sugar, butter, salt, flour and eggs come first, because baking recipes share so many ingredients, and onion does not arrive until the 38th place.

Even a kitchen with 300 different ingredients can make only about one recipe in four, and another 662,164 recipes would be just one ingredient short. The missing thing is different almost every time: the most common one, unsweetened chocolate, is behind only 1,549 of them. The rest are spread across thousands of other ingredients.

That is why the finder below shows you two things: what you can cook now, and what a single extra ingredient would unlock.

What can I cook?

Add what you have in your kitchen. The finder searches 753,765 recipes from twelve recipe websites that are still online and shows the ones you can make, plus the ones you are one ingredient away from. Each result links to the recipe on its own site.

Nothing added yet. Try "Add the basics", then add one or two things from your fridge.

The finder knows the 1,000 most common ingredients. It treats water as something you always have and does not know about quantities, so check the recipe before you start.

Get the next one free

The Data Drop sends one data story like this most Tuesdays. It's free, and you can unsubscribe whenever you like.

How we did it

The recipes come from RecipeNLG (Bień and others, 2020), 2,231,142 recipes gathered from recipe websites, each with a list of ingredient names that the researchers pulled from the original ingredient lines. We removed recipes with the same name and the same ingredients, which left 2,089,091. This page publishes counts, and the finder shows only each recipe's name and a link to the site it came from.

We tidied the ingredient names by removing words like chopped, fresh and large, turning plurals into singulars and merging common duplicates, so unsalted butter counts as butter and catsup counts as ketchup. Some things a cook would call the same are still counted separately, like chicken and chicken breast, or banana and mashed bananas. Water is left out. Dish names were grouped after removing words like easy, best, homemade and Grandma's. Brand names were matched in the original ingredient text.

Oven temperatures are numbers between 200 and 550 followed by a degree sign or the word degrees in the method. "The closest pairs" compares how often two ingredients appear together with how often they would if they were independent. "How far your kitchen gets you" adds ingredients one at a time, always picking the one that completes the most recipes, and counts a recipe only when every ingredient is on the shelf.

The finder covers recipes with up to 16 ingredients from Food.com, Allrecipes, Epicurious, MyRecipes, Cookpad, Taste of Home, Food Network, Food52, Food & Wine, Serious Eats, Delish and Land O'Lakes, because the other sources in the collection, including cookbooks.com, are no longer online. The collection leans heavily on American websites, so all of this describes American home cooking as it is written online.

  • Bień M, Gilski M, Maciejewska M, Taisner W, Wiśniewski D, Ławrynowicz A. RecipeNLG: A Cooking Recipes Dataset for Semi-Structured Text Generation. INLG 2020.
  • Eat Your Books, Why is 350 degrees such a common oven temperature? (2021).

sheets.works is not affiliated with any website, brand or company mentioned.